Best Stainable Wood Filler Reviews (2020): Our Top Recommendations

Last Updated: by Peter Lynn

Best Stainable Wood Filler ReviewsGot cracks, scratches, holes or gouges on wood that are difficult to hide? Homes can succumb to damage overtime. Rather than replace them completely, try restoring them first. Use a wood filler to repair them. We highly suggest getting a stainable wood filler, to get the filler to look like the original color and composition of the wood. There are a lot of products out there that can offer you this benefit, but we will help you narrow down the products to the ones that are easy to use, can last for a long time and can take a stain.

Best Stainable Wood Filler 2020 Reviews

These are the stainable wood fillers you should get:

To decide which one you should get, check the information below:

1. Elmer’s E887Q Stainable Wood Filler

Elmer’s E887Q

Click for Price

Elmer’s make a variety of wood fillers but if you want the results to be stainable, get this one instead. This 3.25-ounce wood filler effectively fills up gouges and holes. It contains real wood fibers to make the end result look more natural. You can sand it and stain it. It is impervious to cracking and shrinking and there is very little clean-up needed later. Just use water to get rid of the excess.

This product comes in a handy tube that you can easily store. It also dispenses products easily and reseals when no longer needed. The formula is solvent-free, which makes it safer to use around as it doesn’t emit strong fumes.

Pros:

This really produces natural results. The wood fibers in it help you fill up those gaps, holes and crevices and not draw attention to that spot because this one blends in nicely.

It is easy to apply. Since it comes in tube form, you can dispense the right amount of product directly on the spot. This helps prevent wasting product. You can also use this for a long time since it is not as prone to drying up as those wood fillers that come in tubs.

It does not shrink or crack overtime. Because of this, it can also be used on the exterior of your home. Even when exposed to rain or shine, it still holds up quite well.

It holds stains as well. You can make it match even further with your wood color. You can build it up and use as much color as you want.

It holds up well against sanding, so you can prep the work area and not worry this will come off. You can even use your high-speed sander on this.

It doesn’t leave behind an unwanted odor since it is free from solvent.

This dries up really hard. It is even harder than the wood itself.

The texture and consistency of this one is quite thick and dense, so you can mold it to fit in those deeper holes and gouges.

Cons:

Some said for its price, it has a small quantity.

2. Minwax 42853000 Stainable Wood Filler

Minwax 42853000

Click for Price

Make your home look new again and seal those cracks, holes and minor gouges with the help of this wood filler. It is stainable and especially formulated to work with the wood stains from the same brand. You can use both water and oil-based stains on this filler. It also accepts paint, great for those wood panelings or siding that require some sprucing up.

This is ideal for both indoor and outdoor use. It has a latex formula that only requires soap and water for cleanup. It dries fast as well, so you can stain or sand it afterwards. This can be used in areas where you might need to hold nails or screws. It produces tough and shrink-resistant results.

Pros:

It is easy to use. You can build it up easily until you have patched up the holes and reached the desired surface. Use a sharp scraper to get rid of excess.

It hardens up real fast. It makes quick work of patching up damaged wood surfaces. Since it hardens up fast, you can sand it right after. No need to wait for a long time.

It sticks to wood easily unlike others that might come off easily when the wood is not properly dry.

It can hold larger screws or even bolts because it hardens up easily. It is even harder than the original wood material, so you can use this in a wood where you will need to install bolts and screws.

It can be sanded, primed and then painted as well. It also holds stains fairly easily. It is even flexible enough to accommodate oil and water-based stains.

You can mix this easily after opening it. It has a mixable consistency, unlike other solutions where the oil separates from the rest of the materials and then makes it difficult to mix them in.

For the amount you are getting, this actually has a good price.

Cons:

If others like how fast it hardens, some also find it more difficult to work with, especially when working with more holes.  

3. FamoWood 40022126 Latex Wood Filler

FamoWood 40022126

Click for Price

If you are looking for something that doesn’t dry up as quickly as the previous wood filler, get this one. It dries up in 15 minutes, so you still have more time to work on sealing those holes and gouges before it completely dries up. It doesn’t contain solvent so it won’t emit an unwanted odor. It is also easy to clean up.

Once it hardens, it is virtually impenetrable. It doesn’t shrink or crack. You can also sand, stain and paint over it. You can even use it for furniture and cabinets.

Pros:

This is one of the easiest to work with. Since it doesn’t harden up that quickly, you still have plenty of time to build it up and seal holes. It does dry up nicely, making way for easier sanding and staining. It has a similar consistency to wood once it dries up.

This is an eco-friendly choice. It is solvent-free and does not leave chemicals behind. It doesn’t stick like many wood fillers out there.

It looks like real hardwood after being sanded and stained.

You can clean this up easily. Simply use water and soap to get rid of the excess.

It stays in place and holds up well against a lot of abuse. It doesn’t crack and doesn’t shrink as well.

Cons:

There were those who said this needs to be re-sealed once it opens or it can dry up.

4. 3M Bondo Home Solutions Wood Filler

3M Bondo

Click for Price

Restore your damaged doors, windows, siding, furniture and fencing with the help of this wood filler. It is easy to work with. It dries up well. Once it dries up, it can then be sanded and stained. It also accepts paint. It can work on rotted out wood as well. Apply a wood stabilizer and then once it has dried up, use this wood filler. Once applied and dried up, it blends in well with the composition of the wood, so you can plane, drill, saw or route it just like what you would do with real wood.

Pros:

Many people find this easy to work with. You can use as much or as little hardener as you prefer, depending on how much you want to work with this.

It is easy to sand it down. It cleans up easily after so you are left with a smooth finish.

Many people have used this in more serious cases of rotting, and they did not encounter any issues.

It does not shrink over time. It holds up its shape well. It also doesn’t crack. There were those who have used this on their house and said this did not crack even after a few years.

Cons:

It tends to emit strong fumes, so you need to ventilate your work area. It also hardens up fast, so make sure you work quickly.

Which Stainable Wood Filler Should You Get?

Easy to Use: Elmer’s E887Q Stainable Wood Filler. This is easier to dispense than those in tubs because you can dispense just the right amount of product. It also has a natural appearance and can take stains and sanding pretty well. The price is also affordable but in a small tube that might only be enough for a few cracks and gouges.

Hardens Up Fast: Minwax 42853000 Stainable Wood Filler. If you like something that hardens up fast, this is an ideal choice for you. It is easy to fill holes and cracks with this product and when it dries up, it is quite solid and hard, so you can install nails and screws with ease.

Better for the Environment: FamoWood 40022126 Latex Wood Filler. Get this wood filler if you want a solvent-free filler that doesn’t have a strong scent and won’t leave off chemicals smells. This is also easier to work with since it is pliable and doesn’t dry up too fast. It is affordable and once it dries up, it doesn’t shrink.

Long-Lasting Effect: 3M Bondo Home Solutions Wood Filler. This one has earned its reputation for being one of the most durable wood fillers. It stays in place and doesn’t crack or shrivel overtime. If you want to seal bigger cracks or rotted out wood, this is also one of the most effective. You won’t have to do re-touching or re-do the sealing process in the future.

Some Tips to Keep in Mind When Buying a Stainable Wood Filler

Not all stainable wood fillers out there are the same. You never really know what you are getting when it comes to how fast they harden up and their consistency. To make sure you are getting a good one, here are some tips to consider:

  • Choose something that won’t emit strong fumes.

If you are going to work indoors, you would want to get something that doesn’t emit a strong smell. If possible, go for those free from solvent. They are easier to work with as solvent smell can be strong, especially when you are working in enclosed spaces.

  • Go for something with a consistency that is easy to build up.

If it is too thick, you might have trouble filling up irregular crevices. This is why it is more ideal to get something that has medium-thick consistency, so it can retain its shape while still completely filling up the holes, even the ones that are irregular-shaped.

  • It should harden up fast.

Ideally, you would want to buy something that hardens up fast, so you can also sand it down and then stain or paint it quickly afterwards. However, make sure it doesn’t harden up too fast. Some wood fillers actually harden up in less than 5 minutes. That can be difficult to work with since you won’t have time to apply the filler carefully. That could also mean you will have to prepare small and separate batches of the wood filler when you need to seal more holes.

  • Make sure it has a long shelf life.

The shelf life of the wood filler will depend on how well the container is sealed. If air can easily get in, it can harden up overtime or the oils in it might separate from the other ingredients. Better get something in a smaller size, so you are not stuck with a big tub of wood filler.

  • It should hold stains well.

There are those with formulations that are difficult to stain. You might need to re-apply the stain to get your desired results. Also find out what stains the wood filler can accommodate. Some can accommodate both oil and water-based stains.

Conclusion

Are there more woodworking tools and products you are looking for? Check out our homepage for some more reviews and product information. You just might find what you are looking for from our product reviews and buying guides.